Research Results Show New Technique for
Treating Brain Aneurysms is Superior to Surgery

by Tom Moore


IOWA CITY, Iowa - Results of a study in the October 26, 2002, issue of Lancet show that researchers, including a member of a University of Iowa Health Care team, have determined that a new approach to treating aneurysms in the brain is superior to surgery.

Researchers at 44 medical centers in Australia, Europe and North America participated in the International Subarachnoid Aneurysm Trial (ISAT). The study's investigators ended the trial early because the early results showed the new technique achieved better outcomes for patients than traditional surgery.


A brain aneurysm is an abnormal bulging outward of the wall of an artery. The defect is most common among people between the ages of 35 and 60. Brain aneurysms can cause a stroke when they rupture and blood flows into the brain or the space closely surrounding the brain.

The traditional treatment for a ruptured brain aneurysm was surgery. Neurosurgeons placed metal clips across the neck of the aneurysm in an effort to stop arterial blood from escaping into the brain.

In contrast to surgery, a less-invasive approach uses a technique called endovascular treatment. Interventional neuroradiologists insert a small plastic tube called a catheter through an incision in the patient's leg into the femoral artery, and through the use of X-ray guidance, navigate the catheter through the vascular system into the brain and inside the aneurysm. Next, the interventional neuroradiologist threads tiny platinum coils through the catheter into the aneurysm, obstructing the blood flow into the aneurysm.

Researchers say that the ISAT results indicate that treating ruptured brain aneurysms with coils - called embolization - results in better outcomes for patients when compared to the surgical placement of clips. John C. Chaloupka, M.D., professor and director of the Interventional Neuroradiology Service at the University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics, is an internationally recognized expert in the endovascular treatment of brain aneurysms. He has served in various advisory and scientific capacities for several endovascular clinical trials, including a recently proposed international clinical trial comparing outcomes of clipping versus coiling of unruptured aneurysms called ISUIA (International Study of Unruptured Intracranial Aneurysms). "The ISAT Study results provide a very important, albeit preliminary step in changing the basic management paradigms of intracranial aneurysms, which will eventually transition endovascular techniques into a first line or primary treatment modality " said Chaloupka.

Investigators ended the study early when a planned analysis of the early results showed that the data about the endovascular technique's superiority were so convincing that to have continued enrolling patients would have been considered unethical.

Dr. Chaloupka is one of the first physicians in the world to perform this endovascular technique of deploying micro-coils in brain aneurysms, which was developed at the UCLA Medical Center between 1990-91. For over a decade he has performed several hundred of these micro-coil embolization procedures. Currently, University of Iowa Health Care specialists led by Dr. Chaloupka perform micro-coil embolization in 100-120 brain aneurysms per year, making UIHC one of the busiest centers in the nation. Seon Kyu Lee, M.D., assistant professor of Radiology at UIHC, participated in ISAT while at the University of Toronto. "Although we will need to see the long term outcome analysis of ISAT, the early outcome results of this study will now provide a nice opportunity for neurosurgeons and neurointerventional radiologists to discuss the evolving management strategies for ruptured intracranial aneurysms" said Lee.

A stroke occurs every 53 seconds in the U.S, affecting nearly 600,000 Americans. One third of them will die as a result, making stroke the nation's third leading cause of death, as well as the leading cause of severe, long-term disability. Bleeding into the brain causes about two out every ten strokes. The other eight out of ten involve blockages in arteries that supply blood to the brain.

 

 
This site is optimized for IE 4, Netscape 4 or later with a window size of 800 by 600 pixels.
Copyright © 1999-2001. The University of Iowa. All rights reserved.